Best Newsletter Platforms

HomeCompare › Circle vs Substack

Circle vs Substack

Circle: Creators unifying audience email and community in one platform. Substack: Writers making money doing the work they believe in. Same fact set for both, straight from each vendor's docs.

Circle

Free tier
14-day platform trial; Email Hub free under 100 contacts, first 30 days free
Paid from
Professional $89/mo + Email Hub add-on (free under 100 contacts; +$99/mo at 10K contacts) · pricing page
Public API
Yes docs
MCP server
Community · Community repo wraps Admin API v2; broadcast endpoints not documented
Best for
Creators unifying audience email and community in one platform
Website
https://circle.so

Substack

Free tier
Free to publish, no subscriber cap
Paid from
No monthly fee; 10% of paid subscription revenue plus Stripe fees · pricing page
Public API
Yes docs
MCP server
Community · Community servers on GitHub only
Best for
Writers making money doing the work they believe in
Website
https://substack.com

Which one?

Circle suits creators unifying audience email and community in one platform. Substack suits writers making money doing the work they believe in. Pricing changes; the fact tables above link both vendors' live pricing pages. For the rest of the field, see Circle alternatives, Substack alternatives, or the full table.